
BUTTER BAGEL
$3.35Bagel of Choice • Butter
ST. AUGUSTINE · NEW YORK SOUL
Seriously good bagels. No compromises.

FRESH FROM THE KITCHEN
A proper breakfast. Worth getting up for.

THE CLASSICS, REIMAGINED
Your next favorite starts here.





ST. AUGUSTINE · NEW YORK SOUL
Seriously good bagels. No compromises.
918 SANTA MARIA BLVD · ST. AUGUSTINE, FL
HOW DO YOU BAGEL?
It started with a husband, a wife, and a full-blown case of bagel FOMO.
We kept hearing about New York bagels: that glossy golden crust, that glorious chew, that first bite that makes you say, “Oh. So this is what everyone’s been talking about.”
Problem was, we were in Florida.
So we did what any bagel-obsessed couple would do: brought a little New York south.
Our bagels are mixed and boiled with New York water, shipped down, and crisped right here in the Ancient City. We pile on the schmear, stack up the sandwiches, and serve breakfast with enough flavor to wake up even the sleepiest beach town.
That’s Proof It Bagels: a family dream with a hole in the middle, a bit of New York, with a St. Augustine address.
And the little guy in the sunglasses? That’s our Head of Schmear Operations. Zero qualifications. Unlimited confidence. Insists on being paid under the bagel.
Bagels, sandwiches and schmears, made for the best part of your day.
A loyalty program for people who take bagels a little too seriously. Pick a tier, get perks, feel superior.
Discover our loyalty experience and ask about member perks in-store.
We're the tiny place with the huge line. Look for the bagel with sunglasses.