★ HAND-ROLLED SINCE FOREVER

BAGELS
WITH A
'TUDE.

Kettle-boiled, oven-blistered, and slightly too full of themselves. Fresh from the oven every single morning.

Proof It Bagel Co. mascot
⚡ click me
PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY • PROOF IT • HAND-ROLLED • KETTLE-BOILED • STUPIDLY DELICIOUS • FRESH DAILY •
★ THIS WEEK ONLY
The OG Plain
$3
🥯
◆ BAGEL OF THE WEEK

THE OG PLAIN

ClassicVeganSpotlight

The one that started it all. Chewy, blistered, endlessly reliable.

Naked. Confident. Doesn't need seasoning to be interesting.

New pick every Monday · While supplies last

◆ MINI-GAME

SPIN THE
BAGEL WHEEL.

One free spin. One random discount. Redeemable in-store — flash the code at the counter and act like a big deal.

5% OFF
FREE SCHMEAR
10% OFF
BOGO BAGEL
15% OFF
FREE COFFEE
20% OFF
FREE DOZEN*
◆ THE PROOF

We proof it. We prove it.

A well-proofed dough, a boiling bath in honey water, then a hot ride in the oven. That's the whole gimmick — except it's not a gimmick, it's just how bagels are supposed to be.

Our little guy up there? He's been rolling dough since '92. Sunglasses on, bow tie tight, absolutely no notes.

36h
Cold ferment
212°
Kettle boil
1
Very cool bagel

HUNGRY YET?

Skip the line. Order ahead. Get bagels. Live happier.

◆ JOIN THE CULT

THE PROOF
CLUB.

A loyalty program for people who take bagels a little too seriously. Pick a tier, get perks, feel superior.

STARTER
🥯
The Crumb
$0free forever
  • FREE napkins + utensils with every purchase
  • Skip-the-line pickup lane
  • Bagel of the Week and deals alerts
  • Birthday bagel, on us
JOIN THE CRUMB
MOST POPULAR
🔥
The Crust
$14.99/ month
  • Everything in The Crumb
  • Free plain schmear with every dozen
  • 1 week Members-only early access to new released flavors
  • 10% off the ENTIRE store, every visit, no cap
JOIN THE CRUST
ELITE
👑
The Kingpin
$29/ month
  • Everything in The Crust
  • A free dozen bagels, monthly
  • Skip every line, forever
  • Name a bagel of the week
  • Invite to secret tasting nights
  • Merch drop shipped to your door
JOIN THE KINGPIN
SIGN ME UP
MEMBER FORM

No spam. Just bagels, drops, and the occasional dad joke.

◆ COME SEE US

VISIT THE SHOP

We're the tiny place with the huge line. Look for the bagel with sunglasses.

ADDRESS
918 Santa Maria Blvd
St Augustine, FL 32086
★ You are hungry here
Get directions →
HOURS
Tue–Sun · 6am – sold out
Mon · Napping
SAY HI
hello@proofitbagel.co
@proofitbagelco